Skip to content Accessibility info

Clayton Hanley Insurance is a

Progressive Insurance Agent in Columbia, IL

Need a New Rate?

Clayton Hanley Insurance will review your current coverage and search high and low for the best rate available.

We'll review your policy and see if we can find you a better rate or better coverage (or both!).

Need a New Agent?

Clayton Hanley Insurance would love for you to join our local insurance family.

We'll make it super easy. You can even keep your existing policy (but we'll still make sure you're getting the best rate).

Need Answers?

Our small team of insurance agents are experts in the local insurance market. We know what kind of insurance rates the St. Louis community is looking for.

Call us to get answers to all your insurance questions.

Clayton Hanley Insurance
Columbia, IL

About Progressive

Progressive Insurance is renowned for its innovative approach to the insurance industry, particularly known for introducing the concept of usage-based auto insurance. Founded in 1937, Progressive has grown to become one of the largest providers of car insurance in the United States. 

They offer a wide range of insurance products, including auto, motorcycle, boat, and home insurance, catering to millions of policyholders across the country. 

Progressive is also recognized for its online and mobile tools, which enhance the customer experience by providing easy claims reporting and policy management capabilities. Their focus on technology and customer service continues to set them apart in the competitive insurance landscape.

Progressive Insurance in Columbia, IL often includes:

Manage Your Policy

with Progressive

Make a Payment

"Always there to help"

I have been with Clayton Hanley for over 53 years. They have helped me out in so many ways, I can't even list them. Peggy Manes is my go-to person and has been extremely helpful again in so many ways. I feel very lucky to be associated with such a great company. YOU WILL NOT GO WRONG if you are with Clayton Hanley Insurance Company. Peggy is always there to help you as many of her co-workers are.

— Patricia H.

"100% recommend"

Clayton Hanley was such a big help to me. They were very efficient and truly cared about what was best for me. I 100% recommend them.

— Greg A.

"Honest & Reliable"

Peggy is a dream to work with. She is honest, reliable and will work to get you the best price possible for your needs. I highly recommend Clayton Hanley Insurance!

— A. Ohmer

"Highly recommend"

I as well as other members of my family have used Peggy at the Clayton Hanley Insurance Agency for many years. She has been great in helping me to understand the myriad of coverages in the insurance market and what the best and most economical choices are in my situation. She has been there to guide us when claims occur. I trust and appreciate the work she is doing for us and highly recommend her for your insurance needs.

— Marcello D.

"Top notch service"

I have been working with Clayton Hanley for nearly 40 yrs and have always received top notch service. When reaching out to Peggy for any issues, you will get your answer immediately. Always very polite and understanding of your situation no matter what. I highly suggest you contact Clayton Hanley if you want excellent rates and service for all of you insurance needs.

— Steve H.

"This company is just fantastic!"

For 34 years my husband and I, and then our children, have used Clayton Hanley for all of our insurance needs. Car, home, renters, etc… Peggy is a GEM to work with and I always get responses pretty much immediately and she has always done all the work searching for the best prices. This company is just fantastic!

— Deana F.